Return to Issue Page
Centra 7 for Self-Service Meetings,
CD-ROM, 2003, Centra Software, Inc., $80.
Review by Helen Gallagher
Whether you like to conduct a meeting with a whiteboard by passing documents
and donuts around the room or collaborating on strategy, you can get it done
in a fraction of the time with Centra 7 e-meeting software. Workers today are
pressured to keep in contact with customers and produce revenue. At the same
time, travel budgets have shrunk, and people don’t want to be on the road.
They yearn to be home with their families at the end of the workday. Can you
blame them?
By now, most agree the novelty has worn off of email communication, especially
for staying in touch with clients and projecting a proper corporate image. People
are deluged with email and don’t look forward to a message that requires
a lot of attention. Many sincere efforts to stay in touch are greeted with the
“Delete” key or a spam filter. “Did you get the email with
the presentation of our services?” is not seen as a genuine way to court
business.
For these reasons Centra 7’s e-meeting solution is far superior to awkward
electronic communications and traditional
meeting styles that eat time and money. It can easily replace everything but
the donuts. At the same time, you will pay something of a premium for the technology
by comparison to other providers.
Centra’s Self-Service Meetings is scaled to fit the needs of small business
with a recommended maximum of 500 users. The default selection for each meeting
is five users. Here’s how I tested the program in small but successful
experiments:
- A research consultant provided data analysis to a client visually instead
of a conference call.
- An investigative agency shared time-sensitive data on stolen cargo with
field personnel.
- I reviewed a PowerPoint presentation for a manager who missed a meeting.
- A kitchen and bath designer gave a product demo to a customer.
- Five people worked together to agree on contract language.
How it works
Centra’s e-meeting software does require some time investment for a facilitator
to know how to put a meeting together. You have to know what you want to accomplish,
know who should attend, what information needs to be shared, and what outcome
is desired.
Tools to create a productive and well-organized meeting include a self-service
meeting scheduler with an invitation process that’s a snap to use. The
invitation arrives by email, and the participant sees a link to log in with
a meeting code. Each participant needs only basic web-browsing skills. Centra
does the rest, starting with a System Check wizard to be sure the user’s
computer is configured for both video and audio. An agenda builder application
pulls together each meeting’s agenda. None of my tests took even five
minutes to construct. Every file on my computer was instantly available to be
shared.
A meeting leader can give the microphone to other participants and make use
of such features as the Application Sharing tool with mark-up ability, real-time
feedback, whiteboards, instant surveys, and text chat. Application sharing allows
users to jointly edit files, such as changing budget figures during a regional
sales meeting, revising and agreeing on language changes, or editing web content
together.
The Centra system does not support Macintosh computers unless they are running
the Virtual PC Windows emulator program (now owned by Microsoft). This makes
little difference in the corporate market where Apple has a tiny share, but
it is significant in the academic market where Apple computers are much more
common. Some of Centra’s competitors do support Macs.
VOIP
Voice-over-Internet-protocol (VOIP) has been around for several years but is
only now becoming widely used. VOIP works by converting voice to digits, bundling
the digits into packets, and sending those packets over the public Internet.
VOIP can replace the high cost of conference calls and the need to gather participants
in one room. Centra has engineered their VOIP technology to very low bandwidth
at 28.8 kbps (kilobytes per second) for efficient transmission. . Centra’s
technology provides hassle-free access through firewalls and proxy servers.
My home office broadband connection is not as fast as a typical office, but
I found the VOIP offered quality real-time performance for all calls with up
to four participants at my connection speed. During a VOIP session, each speaker
presses the Control key on their keyboard to activate their microphone. Users
lacking VOIP can participate via conference call. Expect some degradation with
a larger number of users, including greater lag time between each speaker. Audio
delays and dropouts can be significant obstacles for online sessions.
Video
In replacing face-to-face meetings, Centra’s built-in multi-point videoconference
capabilities allow live video of participants to appear in the upper left corner
of the screen as each person is speaking. Practiced users might prefer to turn
the camera on for introductions and familiarity with other attendees, especially
people outside the organization, and then turn the video off after five or 10
minutes. In my initial testing, I was glad to put a face to the voice but later
didn’t even notice when it was turned off.
Language
Global meeting needs are augmented by the inclusion of 13 different languages
for the participant interface. Centra allows participants to connect and read
the toolbar in their language. The content is not translated automatically,
however. Text and audio are rendered in the original language unless you have
provided for translation.
Meaningful meetings
Centra’s Self-Service Meeting screen designs are clean and intuitive.
There is no need to wonder where to navigate to your schedule, where to click
to attend a meeting, and how to view documents. Users do not need programs loaded
on their computer in order to view files.
All meeting attendees can use a whiteboard, participate in text chat and instant
messaging, view websites and Intranet documents, and mark up screens while discussing
the content. Users can even click an icon to “raise a hand.” Not
bad for an ad-hoc meeting.
Because of the ease with which you can conduct a spontaneous session, you can
quickly find people, invite them via email using your own address book, instant
messaging, calendars or Microsoft Office applications, or add someone on the
fly. You can load content in advance, provide more on the fly, and share files
to resolve an issue. The meeting leader can even transfer files from his or
her computer to a participant.
It’s quite possible this flexible structure can create a more productive
meeting since it forces the presenter to be well prepared and organized. It
encourages spontaneous meetings and offers new avenues for communication. I
expect some may even find the computer interface less intimidating than traditional
meetings, since all participants have an equal voice, with no power struggle
or filibustering around a conference table.
Because each participant sees and hears the same material, with a lot of screen
interaction, it should be easy to keep attendees engaged. Users should be aware
of the need to recognize each person, not letting a quiet attendee wander off.
Inviting each participant to make a contribution or comment might help make
up for the absence of a physical presence and keep everyone active. A virtual
paper trail including summary and detailed attendee reports is recorded automatically.
Authorized users can log in and view meeting histories.
What total self-service means to you
The program is available as a web-based ASP (application service provider) or
installed on your own server. In either case, it is integrated into desktop
tools with Microsoft Office or Lotus Notes. Click the Centra icon from the system
tray or directly from Word, Excel, or PowerPoint to enter your personal meeting
space, load up content, and invite others to join.
Meeting invitations include conference call instructions unless VOIP is selected.
The message can include instructions to log in 30 minutes before the meeting
and download any large files. Similarly, if the boss is listening in but doesn’t
need the documents, she can participate and skip the download. Pretty slick.
Centra supports file types including TXT, HTM, HTML, GIF, JPG, and JPEG, DOC,
.XLS, PPT. HTML files can include JavaScript and Flash files (SWF). Users need
the appropriate plug-in to view content. Total file size should be less than
10 MB. Not all PowerPoint animation features are supported, and PowerPoint 2002
slides can only be imported as JPGs or GIFs.
Content Catalog
The content catalog allows you to archive meetings and associated documents,
have authorized users replay them, and create meta-tags, allowing keyword searching
of the catalog. This feature scores very high for me because it takes a step
toward knowledge management. The Self-Service Meeting service includes the catalog,
which creates value for others in an organization who might have missed a meeting
or need an archive for knowledge or compliance purposes. I see this as a big
advantage when acquainting new staff with procedures and policies or getting
up them up to speed on product development and marketing strategies. Instead
of all the intellectual property walking out of a room at the end of a meeting,
it’s captured in a repository that has tremendous potential for a firm
over time.
Centra offers SSL (secure socket layering) with full encryption for e-meetings.
For security, administrators can prohibit storage of content on Centra servers
and can automatically remove content from participants’ computers at the
end of a meeting. Password protection is available and meetings can be designated
as private or unlisted.
An on-premise installation has built-in security. Meeting leaders control all
content pushed to a user’s desktop. Centra’s ASP service is in an
operations center that is both physically and network secure. The 80-page online
help document includes information on how to prepare for a meeting and how to
facilitate a meeting as well as technical information.
Demo
Centra offers a daily weekday demonstration of Self-Service Meetings at 2:00
P.M. EST (GMT -5). The sessions are 30 minutes. You
must register between 1:30 and 2:00 PM EST.
Technical Requirements
The technical requirements for the Centra product are minimal:
Windows 98, 2000, or XP (Macintosh operating system only with Virtual PC)
Internet Explorer 6
CPU: Pentium 500 MhZ or better
Memory: 256 MB
Disk: 200 MB free space
Connection: 128+ kbps
Soundcard, headset with microphone
Recommendation
Centra 7 for Self-Service Meetings is an excellent platform for a wide variety
of imaginative uses including sales and customer training, product demos, online
collaboration and brainstorming, and ad hoc meetings. There is always a need
in the software industry to serve the small and medium market with appropriately
priced products.
Centra is not a bargain; it charges the premium of a market leader. Still,
it wins points for scaling Self-Service Meeting to a small number of users and
backs it up with the ease of use and thoughtful architecture built in to an
enterprise-scale products. With the “Start a meeting now” choice,
ad hoc ability to invite participants, and quickly drop in documents, there’s
no reason not to click the Centra icon and hold a meeting. This program is a
wonderful alternative to windshield time, airport delays, and meetings that
lack focus. We may not have been ready to accept technology to replace in-person
meetings a few years ago, but today, the lure of greater productivity with time
and cost efficiency promises great rewards.
Product Ratings
Centra 7 for Self-Service Meetings
| Presentation |  | | Ease of use |  | | Production quality |  | | Documentation |  | | Value for the money |  | | Overall rating |  |
|
|